Sunday, May 08, 2005

Shul and the Single Woman

I thought I would return from Shabbat services at Om Hadash, pop in a video and celebrate my brand new little tv (my only luxury item), and chow down on some potato chips (my favourite junk food) and soda. Regardless of circumstance, I make Shabbat something special. I light candles, make kiddush. I have always said, "When the sun descends, Shabbat descends". There is no question in my mind of the gift that G-d has given us.

I used to not watch tv, and not use the computer, when I was with people. My absolute ideal is to keep more kosher (and that's not saying much but it is much for me!) than I do, to lay the table with beautiful things- flowers and cutlery and Irish linen and colour, and cook the Shabbat meal, or several, for friends and strangers. To centre our lives around Torah- to make it all so beautiful and warm, perhaps spiritual, and very welcoming. And that includes including the strange and annoying and alienating and, well...strange, though I would prefer to not make them a constant.

Today the rabbi (not my rabbi), in speaking about the parsha K'doshim, mentioned, as is always mentioned, exhorted, presented, referenced, endlessly, in many texts, many sermons, many classes, every mussar moment- about loving one's neighbour as oneself. Hey, at this synagogue, you could say it is an article of faith! At least from the top, if not down.

The services included a bar mitzvah. The father has done great fundraising financial things for the place, which the rabbi mentioned during services. It is clear that here is a man with power (I'm not talking about the rabbi). The kid will make a great politician/saviour, with Torah as his guide. The kiddush luncheon was held outside, in tents with heating, for the congregation and the kids. We had small balloons and packets of M&Ms arcing across the table. When I was leaving, I pressed my face against the glass doors of the social hall- wow! What had I been missing? The lights were dimmed, someone was speaking at a microphone, there were exotic flower arrangements on each table. I was glad to see that the food seemed to be the same. Heck, we were missing the party! How did that happen?

I remember with great fondness a bar mitzvah I attended which was part of the service in maybe the smallest synagogue in all of LA. The interior walls were concrete. The ark was a box. The joy was palpable. I didn't much care for the service, but the pride and joy and celebration- simcha- were clear. How could you not melt?

I remember most fondly the kiddush luncheon afterwards. My friend and I hesitated at the threshold of their teeny tiny social hall. Yet, there was the father, moved and heartfelt, who stretched out his arms to us in welcome, and bade us to enter, to share in the food and the joy. I will never forget his all encompassing embrace. To me, this is Judaism at its finest. Or perhaps, a great Jewish excuse for emotion.

It was a Reform temple.

So, back at the tented ranch, I wander in figuring I can get a seat amongst people I know. Can't say anything bad about them at all- at least not those who gave me a ride and at one time, salved my wounds. I want to be fair to them. Truly.

I saunter over and hover at the table. I am informed that all the seats are taken- there is no room. These are people I know. Who are telling me there is no room.

I go over to a nearby table and sit there, amongst 9 other empty chairs, for a full10 minutes before someone joins me. He sits down beside me- the infamous tutor. Geez, what were the chances? We exchange totally pointless words and then others sit down and he is adored by all those seeking his favour with their kids for the forseeable future, and I have ceased to exist. Not that I care in this case because his words meant nothing and his indifference is palpable and matches my own. The food is damned fine. Even though I had asked for a ride from someone at said Table of Rejection earlier (and they are very nice people), I find myself leaving early. Pardon me while I cry.

Craning my neck, I noted that the seats I was not allowed to inhabit were taken by the lay cantor and the Pres of the synagogue. Reservations. I never knew!

I actually exited crying. Cried on the buses (it takes me an hour and a half) all the way home. I cannot fault these people for acting obliviously. Yet I do fault them for not seeing past their own comfort. I live in a state of perpetual ambivalence.

Living Torah, in my eyes, is not easy or comfortable. It means forever placing your needs second to the task at hand. And what is that task? To show and bring people closer to the Torah- to be a light to our own nation and the rest of the nations. One would think that in the midst of so much personal abundance (not necessarily material), people would share honourably and with good heart. My bad, for thinking it.

I am in such a raw place where it just does not take much to trigger me. I have decided that finally, though I admire the rabbi's efforts, etc., and the superficial friendliness of some members, man, I hate being at this shul. I was thrown out of my seat once because "someone else" was going to be sitting there, in the midst of a whole lot of empty seats. This being my attempt to get to know the "regulars".

I think I just can't care to stay. If you are single, forget it. If you are single, you must make your own way in spite of the crap thrown at you. If you are a single woman, forget it. I think I've found my mantra.

Judaism and Jews, no matter what the f you say, you fail us, cause you can't get out of your own frickin navels. And that's putting it kindly. And everyone stop telling me "they are only human". Heck, then I may as well have subscribed to another religion. And if you don't understand that then you don't understand Torah and what makes it so especially beautiful and singular and compelling.

I have decided to leave this synagogue.

(Esther, over at My Urban Kvetch eloquently voiced her own concerns on the same subject a while ago.)


Image hosted by Photobucket.com
Rabbi and Congregant






8 Comments:

Blogger Esther Kustanowitz said...

Your post really resonated with me...

I wrote a post about lighting candles earlier last month; it had occurred to me that, by and large, Judaism is not meant for single people, especially women. It's something I'm struggling with now, too--that I can't find a shul that's right for me is also a considerable strain on my faith and observance...and that's in NYC, if you can imagine that...

Anyway, here's the post in case you're interested...(hope the coding works...)

Sun May 08, 07:45:00 am  
Blogger Unknown said...

I read both of these posts and while I am a married woman, I doi understand your feelings quite well. When I started this journey it was alone...my husband was not a part of it. And I was not welcomed, I was not a PART of the congregation until HE started to attend with me AND we placed our son in Religious School. As I sit now and think I am watching our temple die, is it because of this behavior...to only welcome those who are a couple, who have children in religious school? Is this the only way others can relate to us and if we don't have these things, they simply DON'T relate? I nearly left the shul because of this and even now, I am ambivilant about it's pending doom.

Mon May 09, 05:39:00 am  
Blogger Sechel said...

It seems like sometimes we forget we are people with souls and instead we treat others as if their social role were the sum of their value, and totally determine how we should treat them. I have been guilty of this kind of behavior, I am sure, and I've also been on the receiving end. It's an index of how much I have forgotten about G-d at that particular moment.

I tell myself to resolve that it's not up to other people to serve G-d for me or to provide me with examples to emulate, but it's up to me, now. In a place where there is no mensch, be a mensch.

Mon May 09, 07:06:00 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I'm sorry you had such a bad experience. I completely know what you're saying. Add a child to the single woman and be quite broke most of the time and you'll really find yourself isolated. Sadly, the larger the community, the more this holds (at least according to my experience). I know that there's nothing malicious at work here-it's certainly ommission rather than commission, but it stings none the less.....

Wed May 11, 08:48:00 am  
Blogger Margaritagirrl said...

Boy, do I relate to this one! Especially the Table of Rejection, and crying all the way home. When I was divorced, and had to attend certain affairs, weddings, bar mitzvahs, I always felt the odd one out, and was treated (I think) as a "pity case" complete with stares, whispers, etc. about my "situation". Many times I came home, crying all the way.......usually I couldn't even stay at a simcha, I would just show up, say Mazel Tov, and slither out the door.
As soon as I remarried, I became part of a couple. I was afforded much more respect. But - I was the SAME person as I was before. In this society, the frum world (Brooklyn) couples are recognized, singles are shrugged off.
What a terrible thing. And the interesting thing is, most people don't even realize that they are doing anything wrong. What with all the lectures, speeches, about doing mitzvos and inviting singles, and loving one's neighbor.......yeah sure!

Fri May 13, 06:20:00 am  
Blogger Barefoot Jewess said...

margaritagirrl,

Wow, you were living my life! Except that my shul is C not O. My rabbi keeps telling me people are just people which is true, and it is true that they don't realise what they are doing. Still, that's not much comfort and I can't even rev up some hatred either.

I want to thank you so much for admitting that you cried as well. It hurts, ya know? After a while you begin to feel like a pariah and start to think there's something about you personally. Well, there is- you're a singlewoman.

My thanks to esther and z and sechel and shosh for the tea and sympathy and sad stories...I wish things would change but I don't think they will, for singlewomen. But it doesn't mean I have to accept the status quo.

Fri May 13, 11:26:00 am  
Blogger Margaritagirrl said...

I reall feel your pain. I mean it. This is such a crushing feeling. Nobody can understand it, unless they've gone through it.
Boy - do I have memories...and even though my marriage now is not the greatest, I'm staying put, and trying to live my life independently, develop my own interests and friends.
Remember - "NOBODY CAN MAKE YOU FEEL INFERIOR WITHOUT YOUR CONSENT"
so, decide that you are SUPERIOR - and "forgive them their sins" as JC (oops) said.
Where do you live - which area of the country - East, West.........
I'm in Brooklyn NY and my sister lives in Beverly Hills, CA

Fri May 13, 11:42:00 am  
Blogger Barefoot Jewess said...

margaritagirrl,

This blog is anonymous so I can't say where I am. Otherwise, I would not be able to vent! :)

No, I don't feel inferior- just disappointed and frustrated. Trying to find a way to get some of my spritual/social needs met in a Jewish community. Been talking to MOR (he's thinks that's funny- My Old Rabbi- who actually continues to be my spiritual mentor). He gave me a terrific idea which I plan on blogging about later.

I am sorry that your marriage has hit a low point. Sounds, though, as if it is not going to stop you living your life.
Yasher koach! All we can do when we fall down is pick ourselves up again. It's like a wave, the rhythm of life- fall down, stand up- fall down, stand up, etc. Every day. The msot depressing thing is when you think that you've run out of options. MOR showed me I hadn't!

Kol Tuv

Fri May 13, 12:43:00 pm  

Post a Comment

<< Home